In December 2010, after a lot of shopping, my wife and I finally settled on a nice Dodge Grand Caravan from Carmax. We chose Carmax because:
A) I'm too cheap to buy something new and watch it depreciate as I drive it home
B) Several people, among them my best pal, went on and on about how superawesomefantastical Carmax is
A little over a year later, I beg to differ.
The first problem we had with our limited edition 2005 van was a tear in the seat. It has been cleverly hidden with some luggage upholstery repair glue. Problem is, they're heated seats and I park outside during the day. The butt-warming of winter, followed by the hot rays of 2011's summer took their toll. The patch job began to melt and turn gooey, looking like a blob of chewing gum.
That really burned me up. Carmax goes on and on about how they won't sell a messed up car- it can't have been in wrecks, etc. etc. Yet here was a clear defect sloppily hidden. I raised hell.
To Carmax's credit, they repaired the cut in the seat correctly. And free of charge. Okay, I was thinking, they really are good.
Then, the DVD player went out in the van. Actually, it was partially broken when we bought the van. But we didn't realize back then it was a six-disk changer. When we did figure it out, we didn't really care two trys wouldn't play. Four trays were still four times as many as we'd originally thought we'd had. But when the unit completely crapped out, it had to be fixed. It was the main feature we'd looked for when shopping for a van, and the kids had to have it.
Fortunately, when we got the van, we opted for the extended warranty/insurance, MaxCare. It ran us about $40 a month. For $50, Carmax would fix about any problem, or we could take it to a shop of our choice and get it approved repairs done for $100.
While I could have swapped out the bad DVD player in under an hour myself, seeing as how they cose over $200, we opted to give MaxCare a go. For $50, an electronics guy came out to my work place and fixed the van in the parking lot. Very easy.
At this point in my story, Carmax is looking pretty good. But since it's human nature to complain and not compliment, that is soon changing...
Recently, the van began to make a weird grinding noise when the A/C compressor kicked on (it runs even in winter as part of a dehumidifcation process). I took it to Carmax to have them look at it.
While compressors are covered under MaxCare, it was explained to me that if the diagnostic test revealed it to be some non-covered problem, for example, a bird caught in the engine compartment, I would have to pay $85 for the test. If it turned out to be a covered problem, it would be $50 for the test, parts, repair, etc.
About an hour or so later, I got the good news. It wasn't the compressor- it was an alternator going bad. Unfortunately, they didn't have any alternators on hand, and would have to get one from nearby Lexington, KY. They estimated it'd be another three hours before the part got there.
What if I wanted to just leave and fix it myself- changing an alternator isn't rocket science. It's easier than changing the brake pads. Well... the Carmax guy explained that if I left, they'd have to charge me $85 for the diagnostic test, since they weren't doing the repair. And that if they repaired it, it would be covered under warranty. I looked online and found out an alternator for the van is over $200. I decided to let them fix it.
Next up , I was asked if I wanted a rental car.
See, Carmax is big on you dropping your vehicle off and letting them leisurely fix it. I had taken the day off work to get the van diagnosed and maybe fixed, plus a couple of other errands I had to run. It was explained to me that if I go a rental, it would have to be for at least one day, and they would hold the van to fix it. The Carmax guy graciously offered to put the repair in the system as a two day event.
I opted against this- because I couldn't take off work the next day to return a rental, go get the van, etc. etc. I asked if I could just wait around for the repair- it was an alternator, how long could it take? This produced hemming and hawing and the Carmax guy dropped into used car salesman mode, being all friendly and chatting it up with me about non-car-related things. I will give CarMax credit for this- all their employees are nice and friendly, never rude.
Eventually, I decided to have my retired father-in-law come get me. He drove me home where my back up car was- our old, reliable, 1991 Toyota Camry, still going strong, what with its recently rebuilt engine. No problem, I thought. I could run my errands in the Camry, then use it to drive my wife over to get the van after she got off work. Carmax lets you pick up your vehicle as late as 9PM.
Totally not Carmax's fault, but that didn't work. See, the Camry rarely is driven. When I fired it up, in an unbelievable turn of bad luck, its alternator was also bad. Great. No car. Kids at school. Wife at work. Errands to run.
I caled Carmax... when is the van going to be ready. The lady who had answered put me on hold. She came back and said I'd need to speak the service department guy- he'd call me in a few minutes. Great. Just great. When you get an answer like that, you know it can't be good.
I waited for about an hour, hour and a half. I finally got the call. Seems that at 4:30 PM, they finally had my part in hand. But since they closed at 6:00 PM, they couldn't get the van done- you know, cause they needed to check it after installation, etc.
Allright, I'm no mechanic, but I've changed at least six alternators in my life. The last one I was able to drive to the parts store, get the new alternator, return home and install it... in just about an hour and a half. WTF.
So now it's 4:30 PM and I have no car. Fortunately, my father-in-law was picking up my wife from work, and my eldest child from tennis practice. But what about the next day? Was I to expect him to drive us to work? Maybe he could brush our teeth and dress us if he wasn't busy.
I demanded a rental car.
I was given my authorization number and told I had to go through Enterprise-Rent-A-Dirty-Car. I called the nearest one in my hometown. It was 4:50 PM. They put me on hold after I explained what I needed. For five and half minutes. Then they hung up on me. I guess it was quitting time.
I called another Enterprise. They were much more helpful. And open until 6PM.
Off we raced to the new Enterprise. When asked what car I wanted I explained I was 6'5" and need something that doesn't require me to tilt the seat into the back- because my kids would be in the back. Choice number one was a Chevy Impala. I tried it out. It was liking sticking my face in an ashtray. It reeked of cigarettes. That wouldn't do.
Choice #2, the final choice, a Chevy Malibu. I was bale to fit in it, but just barely. And Enterprise made me feel at home, giving me the car dirty on inside and out. Possibly not their fault since I was renting it at the end of the day.
Now it's day two. I'm waiting to find out how much longer it's going to take Helen Keller to install my alternator over at Carmax. I know I'm not going to drive the Malibu over the weekend.
We'll see where this goes, but I don't think I'll be buying my next car from Carmax.